Mattress Toppers Buying Guide: Everything You Need to Know

Looking for the best mattress toppers to enhance your sleep experience? Look no further! In this buying guide, we’ll walk you through everything you need to know to find the perfect mattress topper for your needs.

Top mattress toppers reviews

Our Pick

LINENSPA Infused Memory Mattress Topper
LINENSPA Infused Memory Mattress Topper


4.5 (114640 ratings)

10K+ bought in past month

Buy on Amazon

A comfortable and cooling mattress topper that rejuvenates old mattresses and provides personalized comfort for a restful sleep.

Pros Cons
High quality materials May take 24-48 hours to fully expand
Multiple profile options
Cooling gel infusions
Pressure relieving memory foam

The mattress topper is CertiPUR-US Certified, arrives compressed for easy setup, and offers multiple profile options for personalized comfort. It is infused with cooling gel to keep you cool and comfortable while sleeping, and the pressure relieving memory foam conforms to your curves for a rejuvenating sleep experience.

After experiencing soreness in my shoulders and hips from my old mattress, I decided to try this mattress topper as a more affordable option than buying a new mattress. It has worked perfectly, providing a comfortable and supportive sleep surface, and I no longer wake up with soreness. In fact, it feels even more comfortable than when I first purchased my mattress.

Our Pick

TopTopper Mattress Sleepers Alternative Overfilled
TopTopper Mattress Sleepers Alternative Overfilled


4.3 (2215 ratings)

5K+ bought in past month

Buy on Amazon

The TopTopper cooling mattress topper provides a cool, breathable, and supportive sleeping experience, making it a great addition to any bed.

Pros Cons
Machine washable May take time to fully expand
Cooling microfiber material No significant pain relief
Deep pocket design for secure fit
Ultra fluffy and super soft
Extra thick and supportive

The TopTopper cooling mattress topper is Oeko-Tex 100 certified, machine washable, and made with high-quality materials to ensure durability. The cooling microfiber material and high-density interior provide a cool feeling and balanced body temperature throughout the night, while the deep pocket design and ultra fluffy padding offer a comfortable and supportive sleep experience.

I recently added the TopTopper cooling mattress topper to my 10-year-old bed, and it has made a noticeable difference in comfort. The cooling microfiber material really does provide a cool feeling, and the extra thickness and support have improved my sleep quality. While it didn’t provide significant pain relief for me, I still find it to be a valuable addition to my bed.

Overall, I’m satisfied with the TopTopper cooling mattress topper and would recommend it to anyone looking to enhance their sleeping experience without investing in a new mattress.

Our Pick

Mattress Topper Queen Size Breathable
Mattress Topper Queen Size Breathable


4.4 (5380 ratings)

2K+ bought in past month

Buy on Amazon

This DROVAN Mattress Topper is a game changer, providing a soft and supportive sleep experience that will leave you feeling refreshed and rejuvenated every morning.

Pros Cons
2-Year Warranty None
No-Slip & Deep Pocket
Healthy Sleep
Breathable & Soft

This DROVAN Mattress Topper is a dream come true for anyone looking to upgrade their sleep experience. With a 2-year warranty and deep pockets to fit a variety of mattress sizes, it’s clear that customer satisfaction is a top priority. The 7D spiral fiber filling provides a soft and supportive surface, while the breathable fabric ensures a comfortable temperature throughout the night. Plus, the innovative technology prevents filling from moving or leaking out, making this topper a long-lasting investment in quality sleep.

From the moment I laid down on this mattress topper, I could feel the difference. It’s incredibly soft, yet sturdy enough to provide the support I need for a restful night’s sleep. The deep pockets ensure a secure fit on my mattress, and I love that it stays in place throughout the night. I no longer wake up feeling hot and sweaty, thanks to the breathable fabric that keeps me cool and comfortable. Overall, this mattress topper has truly transformed my sleep experience for the better.

Our Pick

SameBed Mattress Protector Overfilled Alternative
SameBed Mattress Protector Overfilled Alternative


4.3 (3900 ratings)

2K+ bought in past month

Buy on Amazon

The Samebed mattress topper provides ultimate comfort and support, with its machine washable design and deep pocket fit, making it a great addition to any bed.

Pros Cons
Machine washable May not fit all mattress sizes
Relieves back pain Some may find it too fluffy
Deep pocket fit

The Samebed mattress topper is designed with customer satisfaction in mind, offering a 365-day satisfaction guarantee, machine washable material, and a deep pocket fit for various mattress sizes. It also provides relief for back pain and is made with premium surface material for superior softness and comfort.

I have bought several mattress pads in the past and have always been disappointed, but the Samebed mattress topper exceeded my expectations. It stays in place and is soft and poofy, providing a comfortable night’s sleep. The machine washable feature is a huge plus, and the deep pocket fit ensures it stays in place on the mattress.

When I opened the box, I was pleasantly surprised by the fresh smell and the fact that no washing was necessary, just as the description stated. I have had it on my bed for over a week and really love it. It’s a great value for the price and I highly recommend it to anyone in need of a comfortable mattress topper.

Our Pick

LUCID Lavender Memory Mattress Topper
LUCID Lavender Memory Mattress Topper


4.5 (58021 ratings)

500+ bought in past month

Buy on Amazon

The Lucid 2-inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper is a game-changer, providing customized support, temperature regulation, and exceptional comfort for a truly transformative sleep experience.

Pros Cons
Customized support for different body zones Initial odor upon unpacking
Cooling gel infusion
Plush memory foam for comfort and support
Durable and maintains shape over time

The Lucid 2-inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper features a 5-zone design that targets specific areas of the body, aligning the spine and relieving pressure points. The gel infusion keeps the topper cool and comfortable, while the plush memory foam adjusts to your body shape, creating a personalized sleep haven.

From the first night, I noticed a significant reduction in morning stiffness and discomfort. The topper fits snugly on the mattress and has maintained its shape and quality over time, providing consistent support and comfort. The initial odor upon unpacking quickly dissipated with proper ventilation, and the benefits of this topper far outweigh this minor inconvenience.

mattress toppers buying guide

Types of mattress toppers

Memory Foam Toppers

Memory foam mattress toppers are known for their ability to contour to the shape of your body, providing excellent support and pressure relief. They are great for those who suffer from back or joint pain.

Latex Toppers

Latex mattress toppers are durable and resilient, offering a good balance of support and comfort. They are also naturally hypoallergenic and resistant to dust mites and mold.

Down Toppers

Down mattress toppers are soft and plush, providing a luxurious feel. They are great for adding a layer of comfort to a firm mattress, but may not offer as much support as memory foam or latex toppers.

Fiberbed Toppers

Fiberbed mattress toppers are filled with a fluffy layer of polyester fiber, offering a soft and cushioned feel. They are a budget-friendly option for adding a layer of comfort to your mattress.

Attribute Memory Foam Toppers Latex Toppers Down Toppers Fiberbed Toppers
Material Viscoelastic foam that conforms to body contours. Natural or synthetic latex rubber. Down feathers from ducks or geese. Synthetic or natural fibers, often polyester or cotton.
Support & Comfort Offers contouring support, conforms to body shape. Responsive and supportive, contours to body. Soft and plush, offers a cloud-like feel. Soft and plush, provides a cushioned surface.
Firmness Options Available in various firmness levels. Comes in different firmness levels. Typically soft to medium, limited firmness options. Varies from soft to firm based on the fill.
Durability Durable, but may be prone to compression over time. Durable, with a longer lifespan compared to foam. Durable, but may require fluffing to maintain loft. Moderate durability, may compress over time.
Allergen Concerns May trap heat and allergens; hypoallergenic options available. Natural latex is hypoallergenic and resistant to dust mites. May trigger allergies for those sensitive to feathers. Hypoallergenic options available, less allergenic than down.
Temperature Regulation Can retain heat; gel-infused or open-cell foam for cooling. Breathable and naturally cool; good temperature regulation. Excellent breathability, traps less heat than foam. Breathable, but may retain less heat than foam.
Motion Isolation Excellent motion isolation, minimizes disturbances. Good motion isolation; less motion transfer than innerspring. Poor motion isolation; more likely to transfer motion. Moderate motion isolation, depending on the fill.
Price Range Varied, mid to high price range. Mid to high price range. Mid to high price range. Affordable to mid-range.
Maintenance Low maintenance, occasional rotation may be needed. Low maintenance, may require occasional flipping. Requires fluffing to maintain loft; may compress over time. Requires regular fluffing, may compress with use.

Thickness and Density

When choosing a mattress topper, it’s important to consider the thickness and density that will best suit your needs. A thicker topper will provide more cushioning and support, while a higher density will offer better durability and longevity.

Size and Fit

Make sure to select a mattress topper that matches the size of your mattress. Most toppers come in standard mattress sizes, but it’s always best to double-check before making a purchase. Additionally, look for a topper with a secure fit to prevent it from shifting or sliding on your mattress.

Special Features

Hypoallergenic Toppers

For those with allergies, hypoallergenic mattress toppers are a great option. They are designed to resist allergens such as dust mites, mold, and mildew, providing a healthier sleep environment.

Cooling Toppers

If you tend to sleep hot, a cooling mattress topper can help regulate your body temperature and keep you comfortable throughout the night. Look for materials such as gel-infused memory foam or breathable latex.

Waterproof Toppers

For those with young children or pets, a waterproof mattress topper can protect your mattress from spills and accidents. These toppers are also great for individuals who struggle with incontinence.


When it comes to choosing a mattress topper, there are a variety of options to consider. Whether you’re looking for added support, comfort, or special features, there’s a topper out there to suit your needs.

Remember to take into account the type, thickness, size, and any special features that will enhance your sleep experience. With the right mattress topper, you can transform your bed into a cozy and supportive haven for a restful night’s sleep.

Originally posted 2023-12-05 18:00:27.

Leave a Comment